We Were Here Together Too Walkthrough Guide

We Were Here Together is the third installment in the acclaimed cooperative puzzle series by Total Mayhem Games. Stranded in the frozen, haunted wasteland of Castle Rock, you and your partner must communicate constantly to solve intricate environmental puzzles, survive deadly threats, and uncover the fate of an lost expedition.

Unlike the previous games, Together introduces a new movement system where both players can explore separate (and often very different) areas. Communication is not just a tool—it is your only weapon.

This walkthrough is designed to be spoiler-light for the story but mechanically dense. Read your part, describe what you see, and never assume your partner sees the same thing.

Later in the game, you encounter a long hallway with portraits. This requires timing and description.

Puzzle 5 – The Star Map

  • After all 4 matches, a lens focuses a beam of light.

    • Puzzle 6 – The Prism Puzzle

  • Once both targets are lit, a bridge to the next area appears.

    • Objective: Align prisms to project a beam revealing the exit code.

    Precision: Small rotations matter—report degrees like “about a quarter turn clockwise.”

    Puzzle 9 – The King’s Riddle

  • After 3 correct placements, the king weakens.

    • Final Puzzle – The Mirror Shield

    Ending – You escape the castle together. Congratulations!

    Inside the church, you see a pipe organ and two banners (Blue Lion, Red Eagle).

    Solution:

    This area introduces a unique “shared vision” mechanic. One player is in a dark maze. The other is in a control room with a mirror that reflects a distorted view of the maze.

    You are not matching constellations. You are matching positions.

    Pro Tip: If nothing happens, you have the spatial arrangement wrong. Don’t just match symbols—match where they are on the grid.